Ecofeminism: Fragility & Food Deserts

The issue of food deserts across the world is a growing ecofeminist one. Food deserts can take the form in multiple different ways. As described by Georgia’s Rural Health Innovation Center, food deserts are, “a region where the people who live there have limited access to healthy and affordable food, such as fresh fruits and vegetables. Many factors contribute to the presence of food deserts today, such as the traveling distance necessary to find healthy food options, having a low income, or a lack of transportation” (GRHIC, 2020 – Merrit Daniels). The logistics of food deserts include but are not limited to these guidelines, “in urban areas, a food desert is an area where at least 500 people or 33% of the population must live more than 1 mile from the nearest large grocery store. Whereas in rural areas, at least 500 people or 33% of the people must live more than 10 miles from the nearest large grocery store” (GRHIC 2020 – Merrit Daniels). 

 

 

Food insecurity in the US: An explainer and research roundup

 

Who Do Food Deserts Hurt Most?

One of this week’s readings focused on the idea of a more holistic perspective to ecofeminism having been derived from “deep ecology” meaning that the earth is to a degree independent of the living things here. However, because of the (at times) intentional mishandling of the earth by humans under oppressive conditions like capitalism, patriarchy, and other societal things ,  “environmentalism began as a reaction to the destruction of the environment made legitimate by instrumentalism” (Ecofeminist Intro).  Under what can also be labeled as factors like  human’s cultural individualism and instrumentalism on this earth has negatively impacted the earth and subsequently the environment, because “environmentalism aims to make the planet suitable for long-term human use: we preserve it for our needs. Its goal is to preserve; however, it is human-centered (anthropomorphism)” (Ecofeminist Intro).

 

**Like the complexities I spoke about above, food desserts are the manifestations of all of these things too.**

 

 

Some statistics of Food Deserts

  • A food-desert neighborhood may lack a supermarket or large grocery store because of the costs food retailers face when building and/or operating a store in those locations. 

 

  • One trend in supermarket development has been increasingly larger stores, such as supercenters. This store model relies on substantial parcels of land for the store and adequate parking, as well as roadways to accommodate large delivery trucks and customer access. Supercenters and other very large stores may not be as feasible in dense urban environments or in small rural towns that lack sufficient transportation infrastructure.

 

If humans in specific places particularly women because they are more likely to be the homemakers and caretakers of their households and communities under a heteronormative patriarchal society, even across cultures, they are more likely to suffer because of food deserts. This point was made in our intro reading. It says, “However, ecofeminists argue that we must look at our relationship with the environment through a feminist perspective. Environmental degradation is not just brought about by human-centered thinking, it is brought about by male-centered thinking (androcentric thinking). We must look, instead, to our patriarchal culture for the roots of the domination of nature.” (Eco Intro). 

The Impact of COVID-19 on Food Deserts - Foodbank of Southeastern Virginia and the Eastern Shore

There is a link between how food deserts come to pass in both rural and urban cities. In our Hobgood reading our writers illustrated a point on maldevelopment, environmentalism and ecofeminism. Food deserts as a gender issue will likely impact the environment and women simultaneously. 

 

“Maldevelopment militates against this equality in diversity, and superimposes the ideologically constructed category of western technological man as a uniform measure of the worth of classes, cultures, and genders… Diversity, and unity and harmony in diversity, become epistemologically unattainable in the context of maldevelopment, which then becomes synonymous with women’s underdevelopment (increasing sexist domination), and nature’s depletion (deepening ecological crises)… (Healing the Wounds, 83).” (Ecofeminism: Historic and International Evolution, Page 6). (Hobgood Oster).

 PBS  DOC ON FOOD DESERTS

 

 

Full access to the documentary: https://www.pbs.org/video/food-deserts-luboex/ 

 

Excerpts from the doc: Shirley explains that the food she receives from the church she counts on but is more accessible and affordable  to her then a supermarket because she does not drive and is only getting $16 a month on food assistance. She says without the food from the church “herself and the other would not be eating very well”. There is also an indigenous levels that the PBS doc takes a look into: a director of AICHO tells her perspective of the food deserts she serves, focusing on local nutritious food to give. The documentary does show case multi-views of women living and serving in and around this food deserts.

 

INFO ON HOW TO FIND THE NEAREST FOOD DESERT TO YOU:

https://www.npr.org/sections/thesalt/2013/03/13/174112591/how-to-find-a-food-desert-near-you

 

2 thoughts on “Ecofeminism: Fragility & Food Deserts

  1. Hi Jillian – what a poignant topic to discuss in relationship to ecofeminism! It’s strange that we live in a country of abundance and yet we have people with little access to fresh food and we still proceed to waste tons of food! The USDA suggests that America wastes 30-40% of our food supply! This means that not only are we wasting an enormous amount of the food that we produce, but as you share, many people are experiencing the opposite of this abundance and living in food deserts.

    From an environmental lens, this means that we are taxing the land to cultivate crops, raise animals for protein, and reserve necessary land for these animals to live on. In addition, the methane gasses that are produced by food waste are harmful to the environment. We are essentially using the land for what we need (what we learned in the first week of class to be defined as instrumentalism), and then doubling down, as we cause additional damage by what we waste.

    You raise an important point through the feminist lens about how women are affected by food deserts, as in heteronormative family units, they are generally the ones food shopping. As we look at women with limited income means, the lack of access to fresh food can create a vicious cycle of unhealthy habits. Without limited transportation access, it’s not feasible to travel far in search of fresh food options. For folks in this category, income streams may also be limited and/or strained. This may mean the best option is too settle for less healthy options (convenient stores generally offer either prepackaged options or fast food options, both with little to no nutritional value). With these limited options, one has to make the best decision with what is available. When we eat poorly, it can lessen our desire to participate in other healthy activities, and have detrimental effects on our health – poor sleep, high blood pressure, diabetes, heart stresses, etc.

    Thank you for brining up this topic. In addition to the resources you provided, I have added one more below. It seems to give people a good place to start if they are inspired to take action on the important issue that you have shone a spotlight on.

    https://www.dosomething.org/us/facts/11-facts-about-food-deserts

    https://www.usda.gov/foodwaste/faqs

  2. Hi Jillian!
    I was really interested in your blog post this week. I appreciate how you included information on how to find the nearest food desert as well as the PBS documentary. I also thought the artistic photo by Shirley Cannon was a good visual representation of what a food desert is.
    I was looking at the area in which I live and realized that I live in a food desert. Being able to get to the grocery store is a privilege that can be overlooked by people across the United States and is something that I take for granted.
    I thought that looking at food deserts and how it impacts women and the environment was an interesting perspective. As Hobgood-Oster stated, ” Ecofeminism asserts that all forms of oppression are connected and that structures of oppression must be addressed in their totality” (Hobgood-Oster 1).
    I took a class called Justice in the City last semester and one of the topics that was intriguing to learn about was food deserts.
    There’s a TedTalk by a woman named Devita Davison that you might find interesting called How Urban Agriculture is Transforming Detroit. Davison discusses how low-income communities and communities of color are affected by food deserts due to red-lining, racism and disinvestment in these communities. A solution Davison discusses to increase access to healthy and nutritious foods is to focus on urban agriculture, creating farms and gardens for the people of Detroit. This won’t just help strengthen the community, but it will teach the younger generation about the environment, sustainability and healthy eating.
    Here’s the TedTalk link:
    https://www.ted.com/talks/devita_davison_how_urban_agriculture_is_transforming_detroit/transcript?language=en

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *